Smoley, Richard. Quest 98. 1 (Winter 2010): 28-34.
Amy Hale August 13th 2020
In truth, Eliade’s Homo Religiosus and the axis mundi are probably more cited as inspirational to the anti-establishment Right than Jung or Campbell, but the “truths” of human nature which each professes supports the deeply structural, anti-modern romanticism of segments of the radical Right. They are even more foundational to the European New Right and it’s bizarro world progeny the Alt-Right.
Smoley, Richard. Quest 98. 1 (Winter 2010): 28-34.

The new millennium has quite been kind to Blavatsky. Quite a
few important publications have seen the light of day, and I will be posting a few book reviews of some of the major releases (actually transferring some old reviews from my theosophy blog, more appropriate here).
This book can be considered a breakthrough in
Blavatskian literature. After more than a century after her passing, Blavatsky has
made it into the canon of western esoteric thinkers, deservedly so. Finally,
her writings are considered worthy of serious academic study. The late,
lamented Nicholas Goodrich-Clarke was one of the most qualified scholars to
attempt this task and he does a creditable job, referencing the better academic
works on theosophy that have emerged since the mid-80s and the most lucid and
accurate theosophical publications. It is refreshing to see such a
fair-minded, charitable, positive appreciation of Blavatsky’s works. Although
at a modest 200 pages, the work cannot claim to be more than a basic
introduction, Goodrich presents well-researched biographical accounts to
frame the text selections of this anthology of her writings.
I will briefly list a few caveats that come to mind:
Blavatsky, who wrote two articles about Tolstoy (The Science of Life, a lecture transcription review and Diagnoses and Palliatives, a review of his Kreutzer Sonata) and translated one of his short stories, The Imp and the Crust, felt a certain affinity with Tolstoy’s philosophical writings and spiritual ideas. Moreover, she sent him an inscribed copy of The Voice of the Silence, and he used eight sayings from them in his The Thoughts of Wise People for Every Day. According to Blavatsky :
''We have translated this rather lengthy fragment from the Report of Count Tolstoi’s superb lecture, because it reads like the echo of the finest teachings of the universal ethics of true theosophy. His definition of life in its abstract sense, and of the life every earnest theosophist ought to follow, each according to, and in the measure of, his natural capacities—is the summary and the Alpha and the Omega of practical psychic, if not spiritual life.'' (H.P. Blavatsky Collected Writings, Volume 8. THE SCIENCE OF LIFE [Lucifer, Vol. I, No. 3, November 1887, p. 240]
She ran a review of an article on Tolstoy by Raphael von Koeber "Leo Tolstoi and his Unecclesiastical Christianity" (Lucifer, September 1890) which states that :
For Tolstoi, Life means the striving of man after well being, after happiness, a happiness only to be attained, as we have seen, through the fulfillment of the commands of Jesus. Of these commands the deepest meaning is: true life, therefore also true happiness, consists--not in the preservation of one's personality, but--in absorption into the All, into God and Humanity. Since God is Reason, the Christian teaching may be formulated thus: subordinate thy personal life to reason, which demands of thee unconditional love for all beings.
And Blavatsky adds : ‘’Absolutely the same doctrine as that taught by Buddha and all other Initiates, Plato included. A fact recognised by Tolstoi, though not given its due significance by him.’’
Tolstoy’s concept of Universal Brotherhood was inspired by his reading of Schopenhauer and especially the ideas of Christian love, charity and fraternity in The Sermon of the Mount from the New Testament, although in A Letter to a Hindu he explains that : ‘’This thought appeared in most various forms at different times and places, with varying completeness and clarity. It found expression in Brahmanism, Judaism, Mazdaism (the teachings of Zoroaster), in Buddhism, Taoism, Confucianism, and in the writings of the Greek and Roman sages, as well as in Christianity and Mohammedanism.’’
A seminal architect of non-violent peace activism, in 1908, Tolstoy wrote A Letter to a Hindu outlining his belief in non-violence as a means for India to gain independence from colonial rule. In 1909, Gandhi read a copy of the letter when he was becoming an activist in South Africa. He wrote to Tolstoy seeking proof that he was the author, which led to further correspondence. It is interesting to note that Blavatsky had brief contacts with both men.