Translate

Search This Blog

Showing posts with label India. Show all posts
Showing posts with label India. Show all posts

Sunday, 1 October 2023

Blavatsky, Vivekananda and the 1893 Parliament of the World's Religions, Chicago, part 2

On the occasion of the 130th anniversary of the 1893 Chicago World Religion Parliament, I'd like to present some links that comment on the relation of Theosophy to Vivekananda.
 
On September 11, 1893, at World Parliament of Religions held at Chicago, America, Swami Vivekananda gave a revitalizing speech by emphasizing the harmony of religions and enlightening the glory of India to the world. This day is marked as Universal Brotherhood Day in India and among the Ramakrishna Math centres in 22 countries worldwide.
 
Swami Vivekananda in India: A Corrective Biography 
Rajagopal Chattopadhyaya, 1999, p. 132
Was Vivekananda really the singular sensation of the 1893 Chicago World Religion Parliament? This biography suggests that there are no substantial news reports on record that go beyond indicating that he gave a well-received speech and that the actual sensation was the subsequent result of media buildup.
 

Evan Goldstein reviews 
Heathen, Hindoo, Hindu: American Representations of India, 1721-1893 
Michael Altman   (Oxford, 2017)
not a huge fan of conflating Theosophy with orientalism, but he covers Parliament of the World's Religions/ Chicago Fair Vivekananda
 
Swami Vivekananda, Reform Hinduism, Nationalism & Scientistic Yoga 
Karl Baier  Interdisciplinary Journal for Religion & Transf. in Contemp. Society 5 (2019) 230–257  
Last year, I wrote how US politics have theosophical aspects, same for India, decent intro roots of Hindu nationalism.
 
Vivekananda popularized the notion of involution, a term which Vivekananda probably took from western Theosophists, notably Helena Blavatsky, in addition to Darwin's notion of evolution, and possibly referring to the Samkhya term sātkarya. Theosophic ideas on involution has "much in common" with "theories of the descent of God in Gnosticism, Kabbalah, and other esoteric schools." According to Meera Nanda, "Vivekananda uses the word involution exactly how it appears in Theosophy: the descent, or the involvement, of divine consciousness into matter."[30]
Heehs, Peter (2020), "Sri Aurobindo's Theory of Spiritual Evolution", in Mackenzie Brown, C. (ed.), Asian Religious Responses to Darwinism: Evolutionary Theories in Middle Eastern, South Asian, and East Asian Cultural Contexts, Springer Nature
Antiracism & Spiritual Universalism. Japan, India, & the Development of Internationalism 
Akio Tanabe Apr 5, 2021 
Kinza Hirai Kakuzō Okakura, HS Olcott Anagarika Dharmapala Vivekananda Nikola Tesla World’s Parliament of Religions, 1893 to UNESCO, 1946  
 
“Hinduism, Theosophy, & the Bhagavad Gita within a global religious history of the 19th century
Michael Bergunder - (Theosophy across Boundaries, 2021)
very good text, historically accurate, detailed, precise, 1877-1905 discusses influence on Vivekananda  
 
Guru to the World: The Life and Legacy of Vivekananda
Ruth Harris Harvard, 2022
Recent bio has rather weak  coverage of Theosophy, research outdated 10-20 years, a few good bits on Dharmapala and William Q Judge.
 
There have been various exchanges and comments between Vivekananda and various theosophists. Overall, the commentaries from theosophists seem to have been generally supportive, with some criticisms. Vivekananda seems to have distanced himself from theosophy after the death of William Q Judge.

The Theosophist v16 December, 1894, p. 185 - Vivekananda's Appeal – anon

Theost y1895 v17 Dec Supplement p.15 - Swami Vivekananda in England - (The Standard) – anon

Theost y1897 v18 April Suppl. p.23 - Swami Vivekananda -- E.

Theost y1914 v35 February p790 - Svami Vivekananda & Theosophy -- anon
Good general overview
 

Sunday, 1 January 2023

Blavatsky, Gandhi, and Jewish Theosophists

Since the publication of Margaret Chatterjee's Gandhi and His Jewish Friends, 1992, the relationships between
Gandhi, Blavatsky, Theosophy, Jewish Theosophists, and the Jewish people have become a fruitful area of historical research thanks to the work of people such as Boaz Huss, Isaac Lubelsky, and Shimon Lev.
 
Theosophy and Gandhi: How Mahatma learned from occult group
Mehmet Hasan Bulut  Feb 23, 2022
the Sanat Kumara business is neo-theosophy, very different from Blavatsky, some other uncertain bits, but overall, not bad
'was taught this passive resistance method by his close Jewish friend Henry Solomon Leon Polak, who was also a member of the Theosophical Society'.
 
Gandhi’s View on Judaism and Zionism in Light of an Interreligious Theology
Ephraim Meir Religions 2021, 12(7), 489;
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Nonviolence and Religion)
Gandhi’s Jewish friends Herman Kallenbach, Sonya Schlesin (1888–1956), Henry Salomon Leon Polak (1882–1959), Lewis Walter Ritch (1868–1952) and Gabriel Isaac (1874–1914) were all universalists and theosophists. They were unfamiliar with the post-Biblical tradition, expressed in multiple ways, including philosophy, mysticism, rituals, laws and customs. Yet, since they had their own remembrance of oppression, persecution and racism, they could easily identify with Gandhi and the Indians in racist South Africa. Not as the wider Jewish community, these individuals courageously decided that they could not longer be onlookers. They became engaged and stood up for the rights of the Indian minority, in the name of universal, ethical brotherhood. Although they lacked a Jewish education, they expressed their Judaism by engaging themselves in the struggle of Indians against discrimination.
 
Gabriel Isaac, Gandhi’s forgotten lieutenant
Shimon Lev January 28, 2020
Most of these Jews were theosophists and Gandhi understood that his best recruiting ground for European followers was the Johannesburg Lodge of the Theosophical Society
the mourners came from different communities, which reflected the life of Isaac. There were Jews, among them his brother, M. Isaac, and Gandhi’s Jewish supporters, Polak, Schlesin and others. There were many Indians from the different sections of the Indian communities – Hindus and Muslims, as well as people from the small Chinese communities. They were theosophists, businessmen, making for a very unusual funeral scene in South Africa at that time.
To the best of my knowledge, Isaac was the only European to sacrifice his life for the sake of Gandhi and the Indian Satyagraha struggle in South Africa. 
 
Imagining the East: The Early Theosophical Society 
(Oxford, 2020)
14 Mark Bevir Theosophy, Cultural Nationalism, and Home Rule
The third section briefly shows how this cultural nationalism transformed Congress in the years immediately surrounding Gandhi’s return from South Africa. It is argued that Theosophy was one strand feeding into cultural nationalism, as Theosophy introduced important and largely novel themes to cultural nationalism, including a principled commitment to non-violence and an alternative to liberal subjectivities.
 
15 Michael Bergunder Experiments with Theosophical Truth: Gandhi, Esotericism, and Global Religious History 
This chapter argues that there is strong textual evidence to suggest that M. K. Gandhi’s notion of Hinduism, his specific view of Christianity, and his general belief that all religions refer to the same truth were shaped by the ideas of the Theosophical Society. Furthermore, it is argued that the impact of esotericism on global religious history, from the nineteenth to the early twentieth centuries, needs to be investigated with more academic rigor.

The Polaks and Mahatma Gandhi: A Unique Relationship
Prabha Ravi Shankar 2019
What kind of a relationship did they have with Gandhi, especially after the latter became the chief leader of the Indian National Congress with a unique political ideology of his own? What kind of humanitarian work was undertaken by Polak after his return to England? What was their contribution to the Indian national movement and Gandhi's leadership in particulars. Answer to these and similar questions have been attempted by Dr. Prabha Ravi Shankar in what is perhaps the first detailed study of the Polaks and their association with Gandhi. 
 
Henry Polak: The Cosmopolitan Life of a Jewish Theosophist, Friend of India and Anti-racist Campaigner
Jane Haggis, Clare Midgley, Margaret Allen & Fiona Paisley 
Cosmopolitan Lives on the Cusp of Empire pp 37–61 2017
Henry Polak (1882–1959), a British-born lawyer, journalist and editor of Indian Opinion, campaigned with Mohandas Gandhi against restrictions on South African Indians and against the indentured labour system. Founder of the Indian Overseas Association in 1920, he worked with Indians across the diaspora against racism and discriminations. Most in tune with Indian political liberals, he worked with them for Indian independence. His life of border-crossings and his affective cosmopolitanism were inspired by his spiritual cosmopolitanism. His reading across cosmopolitan thought zones saw his embrace of Theosophy and universal equality. He drew strong links between Theosophical beliefs and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
 
Soulmates: The Story of Mahatma Gandhi and Hermann Kallenbach
Shimon Lev Indian & Lithuania - A Personal Bond, pp. 37-52, 2017 
But this story also involves Leo Tolstoy, the prophet of non-violence, who was among the main critics of Western civilization. It involves Hindus, Christians, Jews, Muslims, alongside with staunch Tolstoians and Theosophists as well as white racism. It also involves two ancient Asian nations on the process of a national revival, struggling for freedom in the age of the collapse of imperialism. But it also contains the most catastrophic event of the 20th  century – World War II and the Holocaust. Gandhi on one hand, Hitler on the other – probably the two most famous figures of their time, but what a difference! And in-between there was Kallenbach, who was on the one hand a believer in non-violence, as a disciple of Gandhi, but on the other hand, shared the fears of the fate of his Jewish brothers in Europe, and particularly tried at the very last moment in 1939 to rescue his brother Simon Kallenbach’s family, as well as his other relatives, from the Nazi-occupied Klaipėda (Memel) in Western Lithuania.
 
Pamphlets on Reincarnation: A Unique Set of Articles in the Scholem Collection 
Dr. Zvi Leshem 19.01.2022
Note the symbols that appear on the cover of the lower pamphlet seen in the image above. These in fact form the emblem of the Theosophical Society, which features a Star of David, an Egyptian Ankh, an Ouroborous (a serpent swallowing its tail), a Hindu Aum and even a swastika, which of course was an ancient Hindu religious symbol long before the Nazis expropriated it. Below the emblem is the society’s motto: “There is no religion higher than truth”. 
https://blog.nli.org.il/en/scholem-reincarnation/ 
 
In Search of Jewish Theosophists  
Boaz Huss FOTA Newsletter Issue VI July 2, 2016
Actually, the foundation of the group in Basra was stimulated by the foundation of a Jewish section of the Theosophical Society, named “The Association of Hebrew Theosophists”. The Association was founded at the end of 1925, during the jubilee conference of the Theosophical Society in Adyar. I later found out that the Association of Hebrew Theosophists founded branches in India, England, Holland, and the United States. The American branch published a Journal, The Jewish Theosophist. To my surprise and delight, I found some of the copies of this rare journal in Scholem’s library.  

Monday, 11 February 2019

Wilder’s footnotes to Blavatsky Indian Letter


1-The "authorities" are not altogether clear, and the matter is by no means beyond controversy. One legend describes the Emperor of India, Vikramaditya, as having learned of the Infant Salivahana, born of a virgin, simultaneously with Jesus at Bethlehem, and as being slain by him when on an expedition to destroy the young child, then in his fifth year. Salivahana was immediately crowned at Oujein. This was at the time of the beginning of the present era; and Salivahana is said to have left the earth in the year 79. Major Wilford explains that this name signifies "borne upon a tree."

The account generally accepted relates that when Kali was about to destroy the world, Vishnu made an avatar or descent for its salvation. He became the son of Vasudeva and Devaki. The king, Kansa, having commanded to destroy all male infants born at that time, he was carried away and placed with a foster-mother in another country. Hence Devaki is revered as Mother of the God.-A. W.

2-The government of Magadha or Northern India had fallen into the possession of the Maurya monarchs, belonging to the Sudra caste. King Chandragupta was allied to seleukos, and his successor Piyadarsi was the prince known to us as Asoka. Having embraced Buddhism, this prince labored zealously to disseminate the doctrines, not only over India, but to other countries, clear to Asia Minor and Egvpt. The cave temples, however, were constructed by older sovereigns, but the Brahmans often seized the sanctuaries of other worships and made them their own.-A. W.

3- Fergusson agrees with this description. In his treatise on "Architecture" he remarks: "The building resembles to a very great extent an early Christian Church. In Its arrangements, consisting of a nave and side aisles terminating in an apse or aide-dome round which the aisle is carried; Its arrangements and dimensions are very similar to those of the choir of Norwich cathedral."

General Furlong, while accepting the theory of the later origin of the structure, considers the temples at Karli as at first Buddhistic, adding the significant fact that Buddhism Itself appropriated the shrines and symbology of earlier worships. In confirmation of this the Rev. Dr. Stevenson, writing for the "Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society," insists that the worship of Siva was "an aboriginal superstition," which Brahmanism had adopted, but imperfectly assimilated. The rock-temples appear to have belonged to this worship, but there is no account or tradition of their construction, and Mr. J. D. Baldwin ascribes them to an earlier population.-A. W

4- A ghaut is a "bluff" near a body of water, rather than a mountain.-A. W.

5- This description indicates that, not Devaki, the mother of Krishna, but Uma, Maya or Prakriti the Sakti or consort of Siva, was the divinity here honored. It may be that the Brahmans, appropriated an archaic sanctuary to their own religion, named the divinity anew, but it was to be Sakti plainly enough. It is stated by Mr. Keane that a similar figure, known as the Shee-lah-na-gig is found in the Tara cemetery, and other sacred places in. Ireland.

6- Akbar was a Moghul monarch who came to the throne of Mahommedan India, about three centuries ago. Disgusted with the cruelties and arbitrary requirements of the Koran, he made himself familiar with other beliefs, finally adopting a mystic theism. His long reign was peaceful and prosperous, and he is grateful1y remembered.

7-Probably Joel, 11,19: "I will no more make :you a reproach among the heathen."

8- The Solar and Lunar races were Aryan alike. The Lunar peoples repudiated the Solar divinities or relegated them to a subordinate rank.

9- Probably the hanging gardens of the Median queen of Nebuchadnezzar.

10- In his great work on Rajasthan.

11- This statement is confirmed by several ancient classic writers.

12- The term Rajpoot signifies man of royal descent. The other designations of this caste, are Kshathriya, Rajauya and Rajbausi, all denoting royal association. After the Aryan Invaders of India bad begun to devote themselves to husbandry and the arts of civilized life, the military class remained apart and became a distinct caste and people. Like the princes of Assyria they are altogether kings and kingly.

Internet References

Karla Caves

Friday, 25 January 2019

Blavatsky Letter to Wilder from India 2/2


Howdah
I will not stop to tell you of the beautiful avenues of centenarian trees full of monkeys above and fakirs below, neither of the Ganges with its blue waters and crocodiles. But I remind you of the ancient city mentioned in the Mahabarata near which took place all the fights between the Solar race and the Lunar.(8) The ruins of that city are four miles from Cawnpur, whole miles of fortresses and temples and palaces with virgin forests growing out of the room's, and monkeys again on the top of every stone. We went there on a she-elephant called ''active Peri'' (Tchamchoala Pari). Can't say that the ride on its back gives you any foretaste of the joys of heaven. There was no howda on it, and I for one, sitting on her tail, which she lovingly twirled around my legs, felt every moment a sensation something between sea-sickness and a fall during a nightmare. Olcott was perched on her left ear; Scott, a fellow of ours, a new convert, on the other; and Moolja Thecheray on her back. But the elephant was the securest vehicle and guide in such a journey. With her trunk she broke all the boughs before us, drove away the monkeys, and supported us when one of us was going to fall. 

Kurukshetra


We were half smashed, yet arrived safely to the ruins and landed near the cave of a holy sannyasi, called Lucky Brema, an astrologer, theurgist, thaumaturgist, etc., etc., another fakir just exhumed and resuscitated after a few months' sojourn in his grave, where he hibernated for lack of anything better to do. I suppose he prophesied all manner of evils to us for not believing in his idols, and so we departed. But the ruins must be five thousand years old, and they are pretty well historical.  

THE TAJ MAHAL·. 
At Agra we saw Taj Mahal, that "poem in marble," as this tomb is called; and really it is the wonder of the age. The builder of it boasted that there was not one inch of either stone, wood or metal in this construction, which is truly gigantic-all pure marble and carved into an open fret-work like a piece of lace. It is enormous in size; sublime as an architectural conception grand and appalling. In Agra, this dirtiest of all towns, with its half-ruined huts of dried cow-dung, it looks like a magnificent pearl on a heap of manure. 
 
Deeg Palace
HONORS BESTOWED BY MAHARAJAH. 
We visited in Rajpootana, Bhurtpur and Jeypur, two independent States. The Maharajas sent us their carriages, runners, horsemen with banners, and elephants. I imagined myself the Empress of Delhi. We went to Deeg, near Bhurtpur-something like the garden of Semiramis,(9) with six hundred and sixty-three fountains and jets, and the marble palace, four halls, pavilions, temples, etc., the palace, covering an area of two square miles, and with the garden, four. It was built by Suraj Mull Sing, three hundred and fifty years ago. But the old palace is two hundred years old. It is the place where a Rani (queen), seeing the Mussulmans ready to enter the fortress, assembled ten thousand women and children, and all her treasures, and burned herself and the rest in the sight of the invading army. 
 
Observatory, Jaipur
JEYPUB, THE PARIS OF INDIA-THE BHUTS. 
From there we went to Jeypur, the "Paris of India" it is called. It is indeed a Paris, as to the beauty and magnificent symmetry of its squares and streets, but it looks like a Paris of red sugar candy. Every house and building is of a dark pink color with white marble cornices and ornaments. All is built in the Eastern style of architecture. It was built by Jey Sing, the adept and astrologer; and his observatory, occupying an enormous palace with immense court-yards and towers, is full of machinery, the name and use of which is entirely forgotten. 

People are afraid to approach the building. They say it is the abode of Bhuts, or spirits, and that they descend every night from Bhutisvara (a temple of Siva, called the ''Lord of the Bhuts" or "spirits" or demons, as the Christians translate, overlooks the town from the top of a mountain thirty-eight hundred feet high), and play at astronomers there. 

A magnificent collection of over forty tigers is right on a square, a public thoroughfare in the middle of the town. Their roaring is heard miles off.
 
Amer Fort
AMBAIR AND ARCHAIC RUINS. 
We went on the Raja's elephants to Ambair, the ancient city and fortress taken by the Rajpoots from the Minas, 500 years, B.C. The first view of Ambair brings the traveller into a new world. Nothing can surpass its gloomy grandeur, solidity, the seeming impregnability of the Fort circumscribing the town for twelve miles round and extending over seven hills. It is deserted now for over twelve generations; centenarian trees grow in its streets and squares; its tanks and lees are full of alligators. But there is an indescribable charm about the beautiful, forsaken town, alone, like a forgotten sentry in the midst of wilderness, high above the picturesque valley below. Hills covered with thick brushwood, the abode of tigers, are crowned with ramparts, and towers and castles all around the ruined city. 
 
The ruined heap of Kuntalgart is considered to be three thousand years old. Higher still is the shrine and temple of Bhutisvara (of "unknown age," as the English prudently say). Read Bishop Heber's enthusiastic narrative of Ambair or Amberi. 
 
Sila Devi Temple
The palace of Dilaram Bagh is another miracle in marble, preserved because kept restored. Its innumerable halls, private apartments, terraces, towers, etc., are all built of marble. Some rooms have ceilings and walls inlaid with mosaic work, and lots of looking-glasses and vari-colored marbles. Some walls are completely carved lace-work-like again through and through; and the beauty of the design is unparalleled. Long passages, three and four hundred yards long, descend and ascend sloping without steps, and are marble also, though entirely dark. The bath halls, inlaid with colored marble, remind one of the best baths of Old Rome, but are vaster and higher. There are curious nooks and corners and secret passages and old armor and old furniture, which can set crazy an antiquarian. 

Sheesh Mahal
THE RAJPOOTS. 
Remember, Todd(10) assures us that the Rajpoots trace their lineage backward without one single break for over two thousand and eighty years; that they knew the use of fire-arms in the third century, if I mistake not.(11) It is a grand people, Doctor; and their history is one of the most sublime poems of humanity; nay, by its virtues and heroic deeds it is one of the few redeeming ones in this world of dirt. The Rajpoots(12) are the only Indian race whom the English have not yet disarmed: they dare not. When you see a Rajpoot nobleman, he reminds you of the Italian, or rather the Provencal medieval Barons or troubadours. With his long hair, whiskers and mustaches brushed upward, his little white or colored toga, long white garments, and his array of pistols, guns, bow and arrows, long pike, and two or three swords and daggers, and especially the shield of rhinoceros skin on which their forefather, the Sun, shines adorned with all his rays, he does look picturesque, though he does look at the same time as a perambulating store of arms of every epoch and age. 
 
Rajputs
No foreigner is allowed to live in Jeypur. The few that are settled there live out of town but permission is obtained to pass whole days in examining the curiosities of the town, We have several "Fellows" of the Theosophical Society among Rajpoots, and they do take seriously to Theosophy. They make a religion of it. Your signature on the diplomas is now scattered all over Rajpootana. 
 
And now I guess you have enough of my letter. I must have wearied you to death. Do write and address Bombay, 108 Girgam Back Road. I hope this letter will find you in good health. Give my cordial salutations to Bouton and ask him whether he would publish a small pamphlet or book-'' Voyage'' or'' Bird's Eye View of India,'' or something to this effect. I could publish curious facts about some religious sects here. 
Missionaries do nothing here. In order to obtain converts they are obliged to offer premiums and salaries for the lifetime of one who would accept the "great truths of Christianity." They are nuisances and off color here. My love to Mrs. Thompson if you see her. Olcott's love to you. 

Yours ever sincerely, H. P BLAVATSKY
The Word Vol. 7 July 1908 (203-213)

Part 1