Translate

Search This Blog

Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Tuesday, 4 March 2025

Blavatsky's Apolitical Stance/Political Neutrality

 

In a previous article, I wrote:

The original Theosophical Society was established with apolitical and non-violent peace- building policies.

Theosophists are of necessity the friends of all movements in the world, whether intellectual or simply practical, for the amelioration of the condition of mankind. We are the friends of all those who fight against drunkenness, against cruelty to animals, against injustice to women, against corruption in society or in government, although we do not meddle in politics. We are the friends of those who exercise practical charity, who seek to lift a little of the tremendous weight of misery that is crushing down the poor. (Letter I — 1888 Second Annual Convention — April 22-23, CW 9:247)
 
More formally, she states her concern about individual reform over administrative reforms:
  
Enq. Do you take any part in politics? Theo. As a Society, we carefully avoid them, for the reasons given below.To seek to achieve political reforms before we have effected a reform in human nature, is like putting new wine into old bottles. Make men feel and recognize in their innermost hearts what is their real, true duty to all men, and every old abuse of power, every iniquitous law in the national policy, based on human, social or political selfishness, will disappear of itself. Foolish is the gardener who seeks to weed his flower-bed of poisonous plants by cutting them off from the surface of the soil, instead of tearing them out by the roots. No lasting political reform can be ever achieved with the same selfish men at the head of affairs as of old. (Key to Theosophy, Section 12, The Relation of the T.S. to Political Reforms)
 
More philosophically, she proposes a stoic attitude towards politics:
 
Unconcerned about politics; ... the Society cares but little about the outward human management of the material world. The whole of its aspirations are directed toward the occult truths of the visible and invisible worlds. Whether the physical man be under the rule of an empire or a republic, concerns only the man of matter. His body may be enslaved; as to his Soul, he has the right to give to his rulers the proud answer of Socrates to his Judges. They have no sway over the inner man. ( [What Are the Theosophists?, The Theosophist, Vol. I, No. 1, October, 1879, p. 7], Collected Writings, 2, 105)
 
My personal view is that the original policies entail that a writer, lecturer or administrator in a theosophical organization should refrain from publicly taking active political roles and expressing partisan political views. However, doing this is not so easy. Elsewhere she states: 
 
Politics does not enter into the programme of our magazine’s activity.
Yet as everything under the sun now seems to have become connected with politics, which appear to have become little else but a legal permission to break the ten commandments, a regular government license to the rich for the commission of all the sins which, when perpetrated by the poor, land the criminal in jail, or hoist him upon the gallows—it becomes difficult to avoid touching upon politics. There are cases which, emanating directly from the realm of political and diplomatic action, cry loudly to the common ethics of humanity for exposure and punishment.’ (Our 19th Century Christian Ethics [Lucifer, Vol. II, No. 12, August, 1888, pp. 482-484], Collected Writings, Vol. 10, p. 82)
 
One strategy that she advises is to keep things impersonal and objective, rather than focusing on specific people in a personal, ad hominem way: 
 
“We may be told, perhaps, that we ourselves are the first to break the ethical law we are upholding. That our theosophical periodicals are full of “denunciations”, and “Lucifer” lowers his torch to throw light on every evil, to the best of his ability. We reply – this is quite another thing. We denounce indignantly systems and organisations, evils, social and religious – cant above all: we abstain from denouncing persons. The latter are the children of their century, the victims of their environment and of the Spirit of the Age.” ("Is Denunciation a Duty?", Lucifer, December, 1888, CW, 10, 198)
 
Now Blavatsky is nothing if not outspoken, so in the short article, Our 19th Century Christian Ethics, she makes a rousing political critique of the treatment of Nathalie of Serbia, which touches upon ethical, religious, historical, sociological, anthropological, feminist, and even human rights perspectives which, to me, demonstrates an articulate, nuanced, informed, balanced analysis of the situation, that could serve as an example of how to engage in meaningful political commentary without veering into divisive partisan politics, conspirational theoretical speculations, religious dogmatism, and thus maintaining a position of political neutrality and objectivity, although the writing style has quite a Ciceronian melodramatic tone to it and the political context is very different from today. However note the remarkable prescience expressed in the article as well.
 
Natalija Obrenović (15 May 1859 – 8 May 1941), née Keshko, known as Natalie of Serbia, was the Princess of Serbia from 1875 to 1882 and then Queen of Serbia from 1882 to 1889 as the wife of Milan I of Serbia. 

Sunday, 19 November 2023

Blavatsky and the Secret Destiny of America, Manly P. Hall

Due to the current political climate and the renewed interest in the relation of occult or esoteric philosophy and politics, I thought that it would be useful to take a look Manly P. Hall's  The Secret Destiny of America, 1944 , as it is considered to be a specific influence on American politics, related to American exceptionalism. This is the 12th post in a series dealing with politics and controversies related to theosophy that are currently being debated. I hope to wrap up this series with a few more posts on alternative archaeology and Buddhism before the year is over, making for a total of 15 posts.
Since I noticed some possible influences from theosophical sources,  I thought that the following study would be useful to help further research in that area and clarify misconceptions regarding conspiracy theories and the like.
The work is a pro-democracy political essay that presents its argument through an alternative view to mainstream history that posits the role of a an esoteric group that has been gradually working for the universal implementation of democratic societies since ancient Greece, with the United States being considered to be the long-foreseen central locus for the culmination of this plan of world democracy. It was written during the second World War, which most likely inspired the anti-tyranny tone. The work goes on to list a series of well-known and lesser known historical figures, who have links to this esoteric group and played roles in advancing its plans. He uses terms such as secret empire, unknown philosophers and Brotherhood of the Quest.
Chapters 1-7 - The Ancient World
The first seven chapters cover events in the ancient and medieval periods.
1- The idea that a world democracy  is the secret dream of great classical philosophers is proposed.  American leadership in the Western world is pre-figuring a new order of world ethics and the need to reconstruct the post-war world is discussed.  The idea that American democracy is part of universal plan is introduced. The political significance of people such as Plato and  Buddha and ancient mystery religions are considered.
2- Akhenaton is presented as a pre-cursor for democratic values.
3- In discussing Plutarch, the ancient Greeks, Egyptians, and Chinese, he acknowledges the theory of Atlantis. Hall uses the story of the Golden Fleece to develop a term called ‘the Brotherhood of the Quest’.  The Magna Carta is presented as a proto-democracy innovation,  possible reference to coming race of Edward Bulwer Lytton.

4- Plato’s Critias is discussed, focusing on political aspects with Solon.
5- Plato’s Critias is discussed, focusing on Atlantis as proto-democracy political allegory. (See Casey Stegman’s  From Athens to Atlantis Democratic Mythmaking in Classical Greece).
6-Plotinus’ Platonopolis project discussed.
7- Focus on secret societies, including architectural builders as social reformers, with mention of African tribes, Eskimos, order of Dionyisan artificers, Hiram Abif, Vitruvius,  Medieval, Esoteric History. Probable reference to The Dionysian Artificers by Hippolyto Joseph da Costa [1820].
 
Chapters 8-13 - Renaissance, Enlightenment, Discovery of America
These chapters discuss how events since the Renaissance have developed the plan of the advent of American democracy, presenting probable agents of the plan, with prophecies that corroborate this notion.
8- Hall presents a theory that Christopher Columbus was Greek and mentions the presence of a mysterious stranger as a possible secret democratic adept, based on a book by Spyros Cateras. Mentions his use of cryptic symbols in his correspondence.

9- Discusses prophecies of Nostradamus, mentioning assistance by the Count of Saint-Germain. Discusses Ebenezar Sibly's astrological forecast for the United States in 1787.

10- Various political utopia writings considered as precursors to democratic revolutions, such as Utopia, Thomas More, City fo the Sun, Tommasa Campanella, Boccalini.

11- The role of Francis Bacon’s New Atlantis in enlarging bonds of human empire is considered .

Serapis flag
12- Mayan civilization considered as precursor to American democracy as well as the seven nations of the Great Lake Indians and the Great Rabbit. He mentions a mysterious old man, Quetzalcoatl as a secret adept.  

13- The role of Francis Bacon, England, Germany, France in colonialization of New England, the role of mystical groups such as Pietists and Kelpius, the role of  Benjamin Franklin as adept agent are discussed.
Chapters 14-20 - Prophecies and mysterious agents in American History

The stage moves to the United States, with more examples of secret participants of democratic plan and confirming prophecies.

14-  Discussion of a series of predictions for US history, found written in A Vindication of the True Art of Self-Defence, 1724, William Hope, in a copy held by the US Library of Congress.  This is probably the strangest artifact in the book. Why a book on fencing? How did Hall find this? How did he decipher it? I could not find any further references on this, except for a William Hope Fencing society that accepts the story as is, but see 2020 paper by Alexander Will.
15- Hall discusses origin of American flag with a story of a mysterious stranger who helped design it, from Robert Allen Campbell 1890, Our Flag,  an eclectic historical writer who also wrote  "Phallic Worship",  and Philosophic Chiromancy Mysteries of the Hand Revealed and Explained. The story is un-referenced and contradicts documented accounts of Benjamin Franklin’s role with the Serapis Flag.
16- The role of Thomas Paine in the American Independence movement is discussed, with Jefferson.
17- The story of the declaration of American Independence with a dramatic intervention of a mysterious stranger, derived from a theosophical reference, A P Warrington, Adept Influences in America, The Theosophist, May, 1938, pp. 107-125. The story is of doubtful historical provenance.
18- Esoteric aspects of the seal of the United States are discussed. He references a work by Gaillard Hunt, The History of the Seal of the United States,  largely based on a two-volume work written in 1897 by Charles A. L. Totten, Our Inheritance in the Great Seal of Manasseh, the United States of America: Its History and Heraldry; and Its Signification unto the 'Great People' thus Sealed.
19- A prophetic dream by General McClellan that  helped Washington in the battle for independence is discussed. It is of doubtful historical provenance. Henry Wallace’s role of getting the  all seeing-eye seal  placed on the US dollar bill in 1935 is discussed.
20- He concludes his essay with a presentation of some principles and values of the eventual world democratic society. He proposes three levels of fields of research: spiritual (religion),  mental (philosophy) and , physical (arts and crafts) and gives some inspirational considerations for the future of American democracy: 'In a democratic way of life the very survival of the State depends upon the intelligent cooperation of its people. Where men make their own laws, they must live according to the merits and demerits of the statutes which they have framed.'

The first Theosophical influence that comes to mind, would be William Q Judge’s well-known article, The Adepts in America in 1776, (October, 1883, with Blavatsky's added commentary), which Hall does not reference. It turns out, however, that the 1938 issue of The Theosophist that he references is a kind of special patriotic American spirit issue inspired by the looming onset of World War Two where the Judge article is quoted prominently. (The issue is from a peak neo-Theosophy period that I do not subscribe too, but it seems to be an interesting historical document.) Besides the story of the Declaration of Independence speech, he also apparently got the story of the American flag from that issue, as well as the Washington vision. I think that Hall would have done better to have followed the Judge and Blavatsky texts instead of the more doubtful ones that he opted for. 
Hall discusses Atlantis in terms of political theory and makes only minor use of Theosophical interpretations. The basic American democratic pre-destination idea originating in Ancient Greece does not seem to be of Theosophical provenance (although discussions regarding Atlantis-United States connections existed even in 19th century Theosophical circles). Otherwise, there is a broadly common use of esoteric traditions (and Blavatsky discusses Nostradamus, relating a prediction of the Crimean War. (Isis Unveiled I, 261. Her main take on European medieval and renaissance esoteric tradition is in chapter 8 of Isis Unveiled, 2)). The Judge text keeps the reference to secret adepts vague and uses mainstream historical references, whereas Hall is interested in more detailed accounts of a prophetic nature, with somewhat more alternative references. Unfortunately, I don't find that the references for the American part hold up as well as the ancient and Renaissance ones, using several popular and Masonic after-the-fact accounts. Both sources note that idea of American exceptionalism is inherent in the formal mainstream history of the United States. It may be of interest to note that both Judge and Hall discuss Thomas Paine, but they give him noticeably different treatments, with Judge emphasizing more idealistic, prophetic aspects whereas Hall, somewhat surprisingly, gives a more conventional historical account.

It is beyond the scope of my post to analyze the intrinsic merits of this work (which would be a very interesting task). A preliminary conclusion would be that Hall’s work is more specifically Masonic, although he seems to avoid making explicit Masonic references  (and Judge was a Mason as well) with Hall being the most obvious influence on American politics, (with Ronald Reagan, for example).  One could argue, perhaps, that that 1938 Theosophist American history article was a kind of proto-Secret Destiny. UFO, alternative spirituality/history/archaeology, and unexplained phenomena watchdog Emily Louise, in a video on Edgar Cayce, mentions how Cayce made some predictions about the importance of the United States, implying that it is derived from Theosophical notions of evolution, but no specific details about this are provided. Note that since all the references to Blavatsky and Theosophy in the video are of a derogatory nature, therefore it is possible that there is a negative confirmation bias and a lack of journalist principles of neutrality and objectivity.  A recent Jason Colavito blog post gives some more information on Cayce's Theosophical connections. 

I would venture to say that both Judge and Hall helped pave the way for the historical study of the considerable esoteric, Masonic, and mystical influences present in the founding and development of the United States. For example:

American Metaphysical Religion: Esoteric and Mystical Traditions of the New World  –2023 Ronnie Pontiac
 
Occult America (The Secret History of How Mysticism Shaped our Nation) 
Mitch Horowitz (2009)
 
The Freemasonry’s Influence on the Declaration of Independence and the American Revolution
Gila Valley 9 Masonic Lodge
 
Freemasonry’s Sacred Space in America

Further Reading:
Audio version with copious visual research: 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eQ6aqKKzrHU

 Recent edition with additional text covering South America:

https://www.prs.org/store/p8/The_Secret_Destiny_of_America__%28Paperback%29__978-158542-622-1.html

Thomas Paine
PS - In light of the proliferation of alternative esoteric histories and conspiracy theories in the 20th century, I would like to state that I do not think that writing an alternative history essay exempts one from the standards of rigorous historical research. If anything, it should increase the standards. I do consider that Blavatsky followed rigorous documentation standards. Specific examples that I use are her review of A. E Waite's Rosicrucian history and her use of the works of Jean-Marie Ragon.

PPS - Blavatsky's esoteric history touches upon a Jesuit conspiracy theory, which I avoid discussing as I feel that it has been overly misused and misconstrued, although I plan on writing a post about it in the future. For now, I would like to state that she apparently based it on a credible compilation of authentic Jesuit documents: The Principles of the Jesuits, Henry Handley Norris (1839).
PPPS - In the interest of presenting diverse points of view, a Jason Colavito critique of Isis Unveiled 2, Chapter 8.
 


Tuesday, 8 August 2023

Blavatsky and Politics

Links to a series of 11 political-related posts from 2022.
 
Blavatsky, American Traditionalism, QAnon, UFO and New Age Spirituality
 
Blavatsky and Traditionalism / Perennialism
 
Blavatsky and Russian Traditionalism / Eurasianism
 
Blavatsky and the Theosophical Movement in Russia & Ukraine 
 
Blavatsky’s Writings on Russia
 
Blavatsky and contemporary politics 1/5 - History
  
 
 
 
 
 
Theosophy and political controversies began appearing on my radar in 2018, a few posts from then:
 
 
 
 
For completion's sake - since my recent inclinations to notice the historical influence of Theosophy in contemporary society, including pop culture, below are another series of posts that are somewhat variegated, but that the strange, changing times have lead me to cover:


 
 
 
 
 
 

Sunday, 1 January 2023

Blavatsky, Gandhi, and Jewish Theosophists

Since the publication of Margaret Chatterjee's Gandhi and His Jewish Friends, 1992, the relationships between
Gandhi, Blavatsky, Theosophy, Jewish Theosophists, and the Jewish people have become a fruitful area of historical research thanks to the work of people such as Boaz Huss, Isaac Lubelsky, and Shimon Lev.
 
Theosophy and Gandhi: How Mahatma learned from occult group
Mehmet Hasan Bulut  Feb 23, 2022
the Sanat Kumara business is neo-theosophy, very different from Blavatsky, some other uncertain bits, but overall, not bad
'was taught this passive resistance method by his close Jewish friend Henry Solomon Leon Polak, who was also a member of the Theosophical Society'.
 
Gandhi’s View on Judaism and Zionism in Light of an Interreligious Theology
Ephraim Meir Religions 2021, 12(7), 489;
(This article belongs to the Special Issue Nonviolence and Religion)
Gandhi’s Jewish friends Herman Kallenbach, Sonya Schlesin (1888–1956), Henry Salomon Leon Polak (1882–1959), Lewis Walter Ritch (1868–1952) and Gabriel Isaac (1874–1914) were all universalists and theosophists. They were unfamiliar with the post-Biblical tradition, expressed in multiple ways, including philosophy, mysticism, rituals, laws and customs. Yet, since they had their own remembrance of oppression, persecution and racism, they could easily identify with Gandhi and the Indians in racist South Africa. Not as the wider Jewish community, these individuals courageously decided that they could not longer be onlookers. They became engaged and stood up for the rights of the Indian minority, in the name of universal, ethical brotherhood. Although they lacked a Jewish education, they expressed their Judaism by engaging themselves in the struggle of Indians against discrimination.
 
Gabriel Isaac, Gandhi’s forgotten lieutenant
Shimon Lev January 28, 2020
Most of these Jews were theosophists and Gandhi understood that his best recruiting ground for European followers was the Johannesburg Lodge of the Theosophical Society
the mourners came from different communities, which reflected the life of Isaac. There were Jews, among them his brother, M. Isaac, and Gandhi’s Jewish supporters, Polak, Schlesin and others. There were many Indians from the different sections of the Indian communities – Hindus and Muslims, as well as people from the small Chinese communities. They were theosophists, businessmen, making for a very unusual funeral scene in South Africa at that time.
To the best of my knowledge, Isaac was the only European to sacrifice his life for the sake of Gandhi and the Indian Satyagraha struggle in South Africa. 
 
Imagining the East: The Early Theosophical Society 
(Oxford, 2020)
14 Mark Bevir Theosophy, Cultural Nationalism, and Home Rule
The third section briefly shows how this cultural nationalism transformed Congress in the years immediately surrounding Gandhi’s return from South Africa. It is argued that Theosophy was one strand feeding into cultural nationalism, as Theosophy introduced important and largely novel themes to cultural nationalism, including a principled commitment to non-violence and an alternative to liberal subjectivities.
 
15 Michael Bergunder Experiments with Theosophical Truth: Gandhi, Esotericism, and Global Religious History 
This chapter argues that there is strong textual evidence to suggest that M. K. Gandhi’s notion of Hinduism, his specific view of Christianity, and his general belief that all religions refer to the same truth were shaped by the ideas of the Theosophical Society. Furthermore, it is argued that the impact of esotericism on global religious history, from the nineteenth to the early twentieth centuries, needs to be investigated with more academic rigor.

The Polaks and Mahatma Gandhi: A Unique Relationship
Prabha Ravi Shankar 2019
What kind of a relationship did they have with Gandhi, especially after the latter became the chief leader of the Indian National Congress with a unique political ideology of his own? What kind of humanitarian work was undertaken by Polak after his return to England? What was their contribution to the Indian national movement and Gandhi's leadership in particulars. Answer to these and similar questions have been attempted by Dr. Prabha Ravi Shankar in what is perhaps the first detailed study of the Polaks and their association with Gandhi. 
 
Henry Polak: The Cosmopolitan Life of a Jewish Theosophist, Friend of India and Anti-racist Campaigner
Jane Haggis, Clare Midgley, Margaret Allen & Fiona Paisley 
Cosmopolitan Lives on the Cusp of Empire pp 37–61 2017
Henry Polak (1882–1959), a British-born lawyer, journalist and editor of Indian Opinion, campaigned with Mohandas Gandhi against restrictions on South African Indians and against the indentured labour system. Founder of the Indian Overseas Association in 1920, he worked with Indians across the diaspora against racism and discriminations. Most in tune with Indian political liberals, he worked with them for Indian independence. His life of border-crossings and his affective cosmopolitanism were inspired by his spiritual cosmopolitanism. His reading across cosmopolitan thought zones saw his embrace of Theosophy and universal equality. He drew strong links between Theosophical beliefs and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
 
Soulmates: The Story of Mahatma Gandhi and Hermann Kallenbach
Shimon Lev Indian & Lithuania - A Personal Bond, pp. 37-52, 2017 
But this story also involves Leo Tolstoy, the prophet of non-violence, who was among the main critics of Western civilization. It involves Hindus, Christians, Jews, Muslims, alongside with staunch Tolstoians and Theosophists as well as white racism. It also involves two ancient Asian nations on the process of a national revival, struggling for freedom in the age of the collapse of imperialism. But it also contains the most catastrophic event of the 20th  century – World War II and the Holocaust. Gandhi on one hand, Hitler on the other – probably the two most famous figures of their time, but what a difference! And in-between there was Kallenbach, who was on the one hand a believer in non-violence, as a disciple of Gandhi, but on the other hand, shared the fears of the fate of his Jewish brothers in Europe, and particularly tried at the very last moment in 1939 to rescue his brother Simon Kallenbach’s family, as well as his other relatives, from the Nazi-occupied Klaipėda (Memel) in Western Lithuania.
 
Pamphlets on Reincarnation: A Unique Set of Articles in the Scholem Collection 
Dr. Zvi Leshem 19.01.2022
Note the symbols that appear on the cover of the lower pamphlet seen in the image above. These in fact form the emblem of the Theosophical Society, which features a Star of David, an Egyptian Ankh, an Ouroborous (a serpent swallowing its tail), a Hindu Aum and even a swastika, which of course was an ancient Hindu religious symbol long before the Nazis expropriated it. Below the emblem is the society’s motto: “There is no religion higher than truth”. 
https://blog.nli.org.il/en/scholem-reincarnation/ 
 
In Search of Jewish Theosophists  
Boaz Huss FOTA Newsletter Issue VI July 2, 2016
Actually, the foundation of the group in Basra was stimulated by the foundation of a Jewish section of the Theosophical Society, named “The Association of Hebrew Theosophists”. The Association was founded at the end of 1925, during the jubilee conference of the Theosophical Society in Adyar. I later found out that the Association of Hebrew Theosophists founded branches in India, England, Holland, and the United States. The American branch published a Journal, The Jewish Theosophist. To my surprise and delight, I found some of the copies of this rare journal in Scholem’s library.